MikePaterson's picture

MikePaterson

image

Global Violence

 FROM A RECENT 'NEW SCIENTIST' MAGAZINE:

THE past two decades have seen an increase in mass violence around the world, including wars, armed conflicts, human rights abuses and terrorism. Effectively dealing with these problems requires an understanding of the motivations that drive people to violence - sometimes to the point of self-sacrifice, as in the case of suicide bombers.

Unfortunately, attempts to develop such an understanding rarely go beyond value judgements, ideological beliefs and vacuous labels such as "fanatic" or "religious extremist". What we need instead is a scientific analysis.

Acts of violence do not occur in a vacuum. The mass violence that characterises the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, 9/11, the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq, human rights abuses in Abu Ghraib and Guantánamo Bay and international terrorism can all be understood in terms of strong psychological motivators that inevitably create and sustain cycles of violence.

My colleagues and I carried out a study of 1358 Bosnian Muslims, Bosnian Serbs, Croats and Serbs in countries of the former Yugoslavia, who had experienced a wide range of war events, including combat, torture, forced displacement, refugee status and bombardment. We examined the cognitive and emotional effects of these events, and this study sheds some light on the processes that drive people from peaceful coexistence in a multi-ethnic society into an orgy of killing, torture and other atrocities (Journal of the American Medical Association, vol 294, p 580).

Almost 80 per cent of participants reported a lack of sense of redress for the trauma they had experienced. When we asked them how they felt about this, 98 per cent expressed a strong sense of injustice and more than 80 per cent reported distress, demoralisation, anger, loss of meaning in life, loss of faith in people, helplessness or pessimism. More than 3 in 5 reported a desire for vengeance, stating that if they had the chance, they would punish those they held responsible with their own hands.

People who felt the strongest desire for vengeance were those whose loved ones had endured captivity, torture, rape or violent death. That was followed by those who had personally become refugees or endured forced displacement, captivity and torture, or exposure to gunfire or shelling. These findings clearly show that war violence has powerful effects that could explain, at least in part, the motivation for further acts of violence.

This fits with experimental work showing that both humans and animals respond with anger and aggression to threats to their physical and psychological well-being and that retaliatory aggression attenuates the feelings of helplessness that arise from trauma. For an intuitive understanding of those feelings, simply imagine your home suddenly being raided by invading forces and your loved ones being humiliated, imprisoned, tortured, raped or killed.

Many other acts create feelings of outrage and helplessness, and the accompanying desire for vengeful action. Among them are economic policies that contribute to poverty in the name of national interests, high-technology weapons being dropped from the sky in the name of national security, invasions in the name of democracy, and humiliation, imprisonment, torture and killing in the name of the war on terror.

http://www.newscientist.com/img/bg/quote_open.gif); background-attachment: initial; background-origin: initial; background-clip: initial; background-color: initial; background-position: 0% 0%; background-repeat: no-repeat no-repeat; ">
http://www.newscientist.com/img/bg/quote_close.gif); background-attachment: initial; background-origin: initial; background-clip: initial; background-color: initial; background-position: 100% 100%; background-repeat: no-repeat no-repeat; ">
Weapons dropped from the sky in the name of national security create a desire for vengeful action

In a globalised world where images of war and human rights abuses are instantly transmitted to people's living rooms, the vicarious effects of trauma also need attention. Evidence suggests that even witnessing such events second-hand leads to similar cognitive and emotional responses.

The effects of trauma don't just lead to tit-for-tat violence. They can radicalise ordinary civilians and can even lead to their engagement in suicide terrorism. It is important to understand that such action does not originate from religious beliefs per se; religion merely facilitates such acts by providing a meaning for self-sacrifice, such as martyrdom.

Understanding is further undermined by psychological strategies which not only aggravate vengeful feelings in the victims but also lead to curtailment of civil liberties and human rights in democratic societies in the name of national security. For example, characterising adversaries as fanatics, religious extremists or terrorists hell-bent on destroying western values maximises public fear and prevents an understanding of the psychology behind acts of terror, thereby bolstering public support for war. Euphemisms such as "collateral damage" and "aggressive interrogation techniques" serve to hide the horrors of war and human rights abuses from the public eye.

Halting mass violence, including terrorism, requires a political will to address the problem at its roots. That requires western nations to revise their foreign policies in ways that do not generate and sustain cycles of violence. Unfortunately, such political will appears unlikely at this stage of human history.

A solution might be reachable to some extent by raising public awareness of these issues and bringing pressure to bear upon governments. People also need to see how their consent to wars is manufactured through disinformation.

This is both a moral issue and one that concerns the safety of millions. Escalating cycles of mass violence might well lead to nuclear terrorism at some stage. It is often said that the first casualty of war is the truth. The antidote to this virulent problem is a better understanding of the truth of what wars and other forms of mass violence are really about.

Metin Basoglu is director of the Istanbul Centre for Behaviour Research and Therapy in Turkey

 

Share this

Comments

graeme's picture

graeme

image

All the signs are it will get

All the signs are it will get worse. And we'll be in the thick of it. Obama seems as clearly committed as was Bush to the project of establishing American dominance by militarily containing serious opposition (like China and Russia), while establishing dominance in Africa, and re-establishing it in Latin America.

The purchase by Canada of a new fighter that is useful only against conventional forces means we are joining the US in this effort (presumably presumably to the benefit of US openess to Canadian business). That means wars for a very long time, and with unforseeable results. The army brass always hated peacekeeping. Now, they have almost certainly ended it forever.

 

graeme

RitaTG's picture

RitaTG

image

MikePaterson ...... thank you

MikePaterson ...... thank you for this article.... WOW.... not surprising but rather amazing.

May I ask your thoughts on what we as ordinary citizens can do in practical terms to help address this issue?     Rather than just a nod of the head I would like to be able to do something that would help.

Hugs

Rita

MikePaterson's picture

MikePaterson

image

 Hi Rita: doesn't it sound a

 Hi Rita: doesn't it sound a lot like research support for Jesus' teaching about forgiving, loving, refraining from judgement? Imagine if the "Christian" nations practised a little of that?

-------------------------------

 

It IS hardly frikking surprising... but what CAN we do? There's a lot of  potential, I believe, in just spreading this sort of information around. Here and there, there are patches of fertile ground. And I don't know WHY, just "for example" we tolerate the purchase by our country of $19 billion worth of strike jets -- instruments of terror of ever there were --- when we have so many cost-effective opportunities to reduce poverty, needless suffering and death from things like water shortages and polluted water supplies, food supply  inequities, the wider release of proven medication... when will we learn the the roots of "terror" are deeply planted and thriving on injustice and that, were we to shed some of our self-interest and LISTEN to what they are saying, we might find it hard to distinguish between "suicide bombers" and "resistance fighters", and that we all might be better served by being a little more on their "side". Something genetics and evolution conclusively prove is that a) all of humanity is pretty closely related and b) we're a tiny part of the total biomass, with which we also are fundamentally related. That seems SOOOO hard to get. 

RitaTG's picture

RitaTG

image

MikePaterson ..... "but what

MikePaterson ..... "but what CAN we do? There's a lot of  potential, I believe, in just spreading this sort of information around. Here and there, there are patches of fertile ground"

Now this is something I can do and I shall.....

I wish I had the capacity to imagine what would happen to poverty if even 1/3 of the military budget was redirected into effective humanitarian projects.    My goodness would that ever make a difference!

Thank you for bringing up such sobering topics ...... I shall endevour to practice the starfish story philosophy and at least do something for someone.

Hugs

Rita

MikePaterson's picture

MikePaterson

image

We are in Canada are trailing

We are in Canada are trailing along like air-headed but hysterical groupies behind a system -- a militaristic, militarily demonstrative superpower -- that totally unnecessarily and grossly immorally is mass-producing predictable fury, righteous resentment and desperate retaliative terrorism.

There is a LONG list of other issues to which we should be paying urgent attention. I don't understand where sense, decency and responsibility have gone but they seem to have slipped off agendas in our part of the globe.

Jim Kenney's picture

Jim Kenney

image

It would be interesting to

It would be interesting to uncover the connections between the upper levels of the military, the governing parties in Canada (Conservative and Liberal) and the US (Democrats and Republicans) and the corporations that produce military hardware that is more offensive than defensive.

MikePaterson's picture

MikePaterson

image

 Hi Besh: I think you'd find

 Hi Besh: I think you'd find that the rich guys do the killing: from Romans to Brits to the Americans... the side with the troops and firepower. And you would find that poorer groups have always resisted and opposed the big guys and, in the end, won out because these contests of power are not won simply by forces of destruction

FishingDude's picture

FishingDude

image

For some reason I can't help

For some reason I can't help that verse from being in my mind of "terrible times in the last days." You can't necessarily equate it with 70 AD or some other chronological time because the "wars and rumors of wars" and "nation rising against nation" didn't seem to reflect the current times it was written under Nero or whoever. 

Much like there was conquest and bloodthirsty warlords in those days, it seems on a grander scale now with technological warfare and widespread across the globe.The heart must change first. Man is the strangest animal on the planet.

You can't even ship crates of food into parts of africa because the fascist dictatorship of armed rebels will just keep it for themselves. Then bands of machete weilding bandits under that government will hack village people in peices. 

Brutal men should really have a reckoning with God. They will... when they raise their fists at him in revelation and curse him when they are covered in boils! The gospel is preached to all the earth and then the time of the end starts.  Look at it out there!

Its all about lust and pleasure and selfishness. There are good things too, families and good causes. But we are now elevating immorality at higher, acceptable standards. Just watch cable network for a little while. Theres  even kids shows I will not permit my kids to watch, and they are usually the ones from american networks.

I never heard of the amount and frequency of street shootings when I was a kid here in TO, and that was in the seventies.Compared to nowadays. 

You got nutcase dictators who are self loving self serving A-holes like that north korea freak! you want him to have nukes?

Oh it will get worse, be sure of it!

Crime will only escalate higher and higher in opposition to government and law.

They will recognize child porn as a legal right of an individual to own and possess. Maybe not here yet but somewhere else. Usually a third world country where guys from here will go to and get a 11 year old prostitute.

The earth is only so big,, and has only so much land mass to tolerate the amount of people and excavation. Water is only so much in quantity.

 

Rising global imperrialistic rule by the EU is where it is headed under a one world government. The chip is in the workings to brand you like cattle right now, I'd say they;ll do it with prisoners. Could be a lot of jargon here but thats what I've been led to believe.

FishingDude's picture

FishingDude

image

Naw its more fun to spout off

Naw its more fun to spout off at the mouth like you do Besh from what I've read!!!!!lol.

Back to Global Issues topics