Okay. I feel there is no way to "fix" the Israeli/Palestinian issue with any of the old ideas including the two state idea (which is really more of a one state idea anyway with the economic union between both halves in the plan). So here is my solution.
One state. The nation of Palestine with its capital in Jerusalem. One nation made up of both Jews, and christian and muslim Palestinians. Jerusalem is made an international city regonizing its importance to all three faiths while still of course remaining under the legal control of the new nation. The palestinians outside the borders are allowed the right of return and the Jewish poplulation is accepted and recognized by all other miiddle east nations and the Palastinian people themselves. In one swoop you would create the most powerful nation in the region and assure the borders of it.
Would it be easy. No. Would the strife disappear overnite between the Jews and Palestinians. No. I would guess a good 25 years or so would be needed to sort feelings out but the time would be there because the new country would have (and indeed has now) no real threat to its existance outside its own borders. Its only within that the problems arise. This is do-able. But the Jewish people and their allies, as well as the Palestinians and theirs, need to stop looking at the land as anything other than what it is. Land. Ancestral to both of the peoples living there. The only weakness and threat Israel has today is from within. And it comes from atempting to refuse to accept the simple facts facing it.
The alternative is a horrific future for both peoples. Palestinian population is growing faster within Israel itself then that of the Jewish population. In fact it is not incorrect to state that as a percentage of the population of Israel Palestinians will in the very near future begin to be able to affect the voting patterns within Israel and thus the government and its policies. These will be Isareli Palestinians with full citizenship. Then what? The Palestininas create their own political parties within Israel to push their ideas? The Jewish population moves to restrict Israeli Palestinians voting rights? The future is not that far and that is what is coming if everyone keeps trying to pretend that the area exists in a sort of carbon freeze.
And please ignore Iran. Its a useless country similar to North Korea and poses no real threat to any capable nationstate, including Israel. Iran is ticking away on borrowed time and the time is almost up, rather like we are seeing in North korea. And if they really wanted to 'kill all the jews' they could esily start with those Jewish people still living inside Iran. Its hot air from a corrupt and crumbling nation. On its borders Israel has been completely secure from any sort of actual attack ever since the treaty with Egypt. Again the only threat they face is from within and their own attempts at handling those threats.
So. Tear me a new one! heh.
© WonderCafe. All Rights Reserved
Brought to you by the people of The United Church of Canada
Opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of WonderCafe or The United Church of Canada

Comments
MikePaterson
The seat of the problem lies
Posted on: 06/06/2010 15:42
The seat of the problem lies in the way Israel was carved out of a former British "protectorate" and handed to traumatised people that nobody would welcome -- wronged people being thrown a crust that belonged to somebody else but that that had enormous symbolic and ritual value to both. It was a monstrous act, even worse than handing Polish POWs over to Stalin as a convenient way to get rid of them, the handing of the Baltic states to Stalin to purge and re-populate, and the blind eye turned to the dispossession and extermination of people like the Sudeten German-speaking Bohemians...
The Allies were victorious and in a state of shock and pain themselves, and numbly tolerant of Anti-Axis hatred, however it was expressed. The Palestinians and the whole Arab world really, were seen as having been Nazi collaborators and sympathisers. They certainly were hotbeds of anti-British feeling, but for some very good, unacknowledged reasons.
There is a deep injustice at the very core of the issue and it's the elephant in the room: the long history of anti-Semitism in the West and racist contempt in the west for the Arab-Islamic world, despite its having played a vital, founding role in Europe's rise from squalor and superstition in the 9th-14th centuries: half of a millennium during which so much that was great and good and ennobling poured into Europe, most notably through the Caliphates in Spain.
The West owes both peoples a world-changing apology and acknowledgement of the immense gifts both the Jews and the Arabic peoples have bestowed on the West. Instead of taking sides and inciting deepening rifts, WE need to set things aright in OUR relationships with Jews and with Palestinians, and with Islam, and that will involve sacrifice and accommodation. While that table remains uncleared of its toxic historical litter, it is very difficult for non-Zionist moderate Jews and non-terrorist-sympathising moderate Moslems and Arabs to meet in good faith and from positions of dignity and authority.
Christians, recognising ourselves as followers of the Abrahamic faith, co-religionists in fact, and as worshippers of the same One God are the missing link here: standing aside and throwing stones and strutting about puffed up with judgemental conceit. Why do we never hear the pain of Palestine and Israel expressed as a flood of Christian compassion and love... and some sincere respect. Who is our neighbour... both, I would argue, and we have wronged both. We are taught to forgive and repent, to take note of the mote in our own eye... maybe we should listen to Christ more closely.
graeme
Mike, your outline of the
Posted on: 06/06/2010 13:41
Mike, your outline of the problem is superb.
Rev. Steven Davis
Absolutely 100% bang-on
Posted on: 06/06/2010 13:59
Absolutely 100% bang-on analysis, Mike!