Tyson
Ellen Leaves Idol
Posted on: 07/30/2010 08:23
Well, Ellen anounced her departure as a judge on American Idol. Since then, rumors have been circulating as to who will replace her. Jennifer Lopez has been rumored to be her replacement. However, the bigger question is, who will replace Simon Cowell? My source tells me that Steven Tyler and ............HARRY CONNICK JR. are being considered as Mr. Cowell's replacement.
I propose a poll. Who would you rather see as Simon Cowell's replacement as judge on American Idol?
Steven Tyler or Harry Connick Jr.
- Login or register to post comments
- Add new comment
Comments
Tyson
My vote goes to Harry Connick
Posted on: 07/30/2010 08:27
My vote goes to Harry Connick Jr.
When Randy Jackson leaves, I will tune out. Unless they could get Geddy Lee to replace him. That would be stellar.
Tyson
Ummmmm...or Christopher
Posted on: 07/30/2010 08:29
Ummmmm...or Christopher Walken. That would be equally as stellar.
RitaTG
Personally ..... I would like
Posted on: 07/30/2010 08:40
Personally ..... I would like to see chasen and jae on the panel!
Now that would provide some diverse opinion and exciting entertainment!
LOL ...just had to have a bit of fun
.... blame it on not enough coffee ...yet 
Hugs
Rita
Mendalla
Hm. I'd go with GR and
Posted on: 07/30/2010 16:35
Hm. I'd go with GR and Beshpin myself
. Maybe have someone a little less contentious like you or Pilgrim's Progress on to introduce some sanity and try to keep them in line.
Mendalla
Mendalla
consumingfire wrote: My vote
Posted on: 07/30/2010 16:38
My vote goes to Harry Connick Jr.
When Randy Jackson leaves, I will tune out. Unless they could get Geddy Lee to replace him. That would be stellar.
But Geddy Lee might actually judge people on ... you know ... their talent and then someone good might actually win. Destroys the whole vibe of the show
.
FWIW, I think the whole thing is just Star Search on steroids and have largely ignored it.
Mendalla
joejack2
So, my distant cousin, Ellen,
Posted on: 07/30/2010 17:43
So, my distant cousin, Ellen, is leaving (10th or 11th cousin depending on the lineage-just name dropping). Why not some good old Canadian content, say, Don Cherry to replace Simon Cowell and Burton Cummings (Guess Who fame) to replace Ellen. At least Burton knows something about music.
MorningCalm
He could judge the
Posted on: 07/31/2010 01:05
He could judge the contestants before they even sing.
Tyson
RivermanJae wrote: He
Posted on: 07/31/2010 01:13
He could judge the contestants before they even sing.
And bend a spoon....using only his mind. He certainly is amazing.
trishcuit
Between Harry Connick Jr and
Posted on: 07/31/2010 02:44
Between Harry Connick Jr and Stephen Tyler I hope for Harry Connick. At least he still has two brain cells left to rub together.
trishcuit
Christopher Walken can
Posted on: 07/31/2010 02:45
Christopher Walken can dance. Did you know that?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7Ky5R-vxns
revjohn
Hi
Posted on: 07/31/2010 19:17
Hi consumingfire,
I propose a poll. Who would you rather see as Simon Cowell's replacement as judge on American Idol?
I'd vote for Moe Howard, Curly Howard and Larry Fine. Sadly they are unavailable.
In their stead Martin Short, Dave Thomas and Andrea Martin.
Grace and peace to you.
John
MorningCalm
revjohn wrote: In their stead
Posted on: 07/31/2010 21:28
In their stead Martin Short, Dave Thomas and Andrea Martin.
To my knowledge the only one of the three who's had a hit music record is Thomas. Of the three I'd go with him.
sighsnootles
consumingfire wrote: My vote
Posted on: 08/03/2010 06:57
My vote goes to Harry Connick Jr.
When Randy Jackson leaves, I will tune out. Unless they could get Geddy Lee to replace him. That would be stellar.
that picture of geddy lee is TEH AWESOME.
revjohn
Hi Jae, RivermanJae
Posted on: 08/03/2010 08:37
Hi Jae,
To my knowledge the only one of the three who's had a hit music record is Thomas. Of the three I'd go with him.
Not Quite.
Thomas has won two Junos (both for Comedy albums) and an Emmy (for Outstanding Achievement in Content for Non-Traditional Delivery Platform)
Both Short and Martin have experience on Broadway which, I have heard, requires some musical ability.
More than Ellen has at any rate.
Grace and peace to you.
John
MorningCalm
revjohn wrote: Hi
Posted on: 08/07/2010 09:18
Hi Jae,
To my knowledge the only one of the three who's had a hit music record is Thomas. Of the three I'd go with him.
Not Quite.
Thomas has won two Junos (both for Comedy albums) and an Emmy (for Outstanding Achievement in Content for Non-Traditional Delivery Platform)
So you're saying Martin and/or Short have hit records? None that I know of. None that you listed.
And say brother, you forgot about this little tune...