Beshpin's picture

Beshpin

image

Is Sex more important than Love?

This is a question I just thought of when I was reading some old stuff.

 

How important is it that your wife/husband/life partner be good in the bedroom?

 

If you knew they were bad and would never get better... would you consider not marrying or spending the rest of your life with this person? How important is good sex to a life-long commitment?

Share this

Comments

Mendalla's picture

Mendalla

image

Define "good in the bedroom".

Define "good in the bedroom". I think that there are a number of factors in play (sex drive, kinks, physical attraction, etc.) in that statement. My good sex may not be the same as your good sex.

 

So, first of all, you need to establish ahead of time whether the two of you connect on enough of these factors for good sex to even be an option.

 

Second, there's the matter of how important sex is overall. For some people, it will be a deal breaker. For others, connecting on other, non-physical levels might offset the sex issue. Some people are asexual and only connect on a non-sexual level.

 

Then there's the issue of how you will handle changing sexual expectations once you're in the relationship. Sex drives at 50 are different beasts from sex drives at 25 and what excited one at 30 might not be so exciting at 40.

 

For me, it's important, but so is connecting on other levels (shared intellectual interests, enjoying each others company, etc.). If I had mind-blowing sex but no other connection, then no marriage (but one hell of a one-night stand). If I had so so sex, but good connections on other levels, then marriage or other longterm relationship is still a possibility. No sex ain't an option for me, though .

 

In the end, it all comes down to the couple communicating about their expectations (not just at the beginning of the relationship but throughout) and deciding if those expectations match up.

 

All IMHO, YMMV, etc. but based on 16 years of marriage.

 

Mendalla

 

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

Tricky waters here .... and

Tricky waters here .... and in some ways there is a great gender divide with this type of question ... i think most women would say love is more important and most guys will say if they are honest that variety is the spice of life .....

 

It is however very difficult if your partner is not, how shall i say ... adventureous in the bedroom or creative in the bedroom .... i think people's sexual needs and wants have changed a great deal in the last few years and the internet has pretty much brought some of those needs to light .... some of them are outrageous other things are just plain weird .... one only has to go deep into porn online to know what i am talking about ...

 

i don't think i could or would or have spent the rest of my life with someone who was limited ....

 

if people are limited in the bedroom they tend to be so in other areas of their lives ...... sex is just an extension of this ....

to generalize i think that conservative people are conservative in the bedroom and vice versa with liberal people .....

which is why i think no sex before marriage is a surefire way to lead to disapointment and unfullfilled needs ...... people should experiment (safely) and get it out of their system or find a partner who is on their wavelength

perhaps it is possible to have those other connections that people want ... emotional intellectural , spiritual and so forth without the kink .... but that just calls for having lovers on the side .....

 

Olivet_Sarah's picture

Olivet_Sarah

image

I think the key here is

I think the key here is having matched expectations, rather than high or low ones. In theory, I could be incredibly compatible with one partner and consider him fantastic, while another woman would not and vice versa. This goes for quality and quantity both; obviously someone who likes 'playing', toys etc. and someone who's more conservative in the bedroom wouldn't be compatible, yet that's not to say either of them are 'bad' in bed. I don't think there's any such thing as bad in this case, so subjective is it.

Pilgrims Progress's picture

Pilgrims Progress

image

jesouhaite777 wrote: if

jesouhaite777 wrote:

if people are limited in the bedroom they tend to be so in other areas of their lives ...... sex is just an extension of this ....

to generalize i think that conservative people are conservative in the bedroom and vice versa with liberal people .....

Can't agree with this...........

 

When it comes to sex - I know what I like, and that's what I want!  

 

(Really, Possums, when I was young and desirable (a lifetime ago) I realised that men had to be trained to make love - and put down the toilet seat.)

 

Nobody who knows me would describe me as conservative.

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

You can bypass the training

You can bypass the training ..... if you keep a crop whip handy

SLJudds's picture

SLJudds

image

Pilgrim - who sez you're any

Pilgrim - who sez you're any less desirable now?

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

She's holding out on us .....

She's holding out on us ..... that's what i heard from the orgy party

Pilgrims Progress's picture

Pilgrims Progress

image

SLJudds wrote: Pilgrim - who

SLJudds wrote:

Pilgrim - who sez you're any less desirable now?

My mirror.

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

LOL it's the boys that do da

LOL it's the boys that do da chasing most of the time

 

 

sighsnootles's picture

sighsnootles

image

for me, its very important

for me, its very important that i have a satisfying sexual relationship with my spouse.

 

i'm with dr phil on this one... when the sex life is good, its only about 10% of the relationship.  when the sex life is a problem, then it becomes about 90% of the relationship.

Pilgrims Progress's picture

Pilgrims Progress

image

Pilgrims Progress

Pilgrims Progress wrote:

SLJudds wrote:

Pilgrim - who sez you're any less desirable now?

My mirror.

I'm pleased to report that my mirror's got it all wrong. I was a steward at church yesterday - and a nice man kissed me on the cheek.

 

All I had to do was smile and hand him a hymm book - honest!   

SLJudds's picture

SLJudds

image

Pilgrim. Normal guys my age

Pilgrim.

Normal guys my age may like to watch the shapely young things, but we are actually much more attracted to women our own age. (Contrary to the assertions from Hollywood).

Mendalla's picture

Mendalla

image

SLJudds

SLJudds wrote:

Pilgrim.

Normal guys my age may like to watch the shapely young things, but we are actually much more attracted to women our own age. (Contrary to the assertions from Hollywood).

 

To quote a meme from my other board: This thread is useless without pics .

 

But, more seriously, SL is on the money. Most of the women that I would rate desirable are ones I know IRL, not actresses or models.

 

Mendalla

 

lastpointe's picture

lastpointe

image

I don't think sex is more

I don't think sex is more important and I think couples can have an asexual marriage if it is what both of them wish.

 

I have found over my 28 years of marraige that sex changes.  Good spells, ok spells and scarce spells too.

 

i really disagree with the statement made that conservative people have conservative sex lives.  I don't think you can have any idea of how racey or randy a couple can be on the inside.

 

You can be very eager to try new things at home with the one you love but not show that out to others.  Why would I want others to know how adventurous I might be?  they have no need to know, they are not my partner

Motheroffive's picture

Motheroffive

image

There is no way of predicting

There is no way of predicting how a couple's sex life will evolve, given that several factors influence that. Lifestyle plays a huge role -- if both parties are at full tilt with work and caring for children, it often gets to be a lower priority. If either of the parties becomes afflicted physically in  such a way as to interfere with sexual activiity, that can play a role in frequency and quality of sexual activities.

boltupright's picture

boltupright

image

No, at least this is how I

No, at least this is how I now see it.

 

 

Bolt

FishingDude's picture

FishingDude

image

Sex must be good in

Sex must be good in marriage (IMO) I can honestly say its better for me in my marriage now then the casual flings and one night stands of the past, becuase you go in with expectations that don`t get met or your not satisfied with the person cuz they have bad breath or ``stink`` or turn you off in some way with a mood or comment or whatever. just being realistic.

You learn each others way and preference in marriage or relationship and accept one another physically and continually improve on it.

 

jlin's picture

jlin

image

Dr. Phil is a weirdo

Dr. Phil is a weirdo misogynist freak and that statement says it all about him.

 

Just because he has money and a show and has some grounding in misgynist pop psychology doesn't really make him the expert he's given credit for.   

For what it's worth, my take on it is that  If sex is the issue then you don't have issues about sex you have issues about trust, projection, respect, boundries, temperance, philosophies . . . add to it. 

She_Devil's picture

She_Devil

image

If you love someone you will

If you love someone you will want to have sex with them.  If you feel that they are disrespecting you or using you in some way you won't.  So if sex is a problem in a relationship than it is problem of a bigger issue.

 

Interestingly, statistically in cases of dementia the women stop having sex with their partners if the men get dementia.  People who get dementia usually experience increased sex drives.   Men whose wives get dementia have no issues with being care giver and sex partner.    Women have reported that after they have sex their husband asks them to leave so his wife does not catch them and that turns them off.  So that shows that sex for men is more physical and for women it needs to be more in a relationship.  This is in general terms.  There are exceptions to every rule.

Motheroffive's picture

Motheroffive

image

She_Devil wrote: If you love

She_Devil wrote:

If you love someone you will want to have sex with them. 

 

This feels like a huge generalization to me, She_Devil. There are loads of reasons why someone wouldn't necessarily want to have sex with their partner that don't indicate lack of love. The biggest one I can think of concerns health issues. Next to that would be fatigue. Self-esteem issues can also play their role as can post-traumatic stress for those who have been abused. The other matter that can come into play is a discrepancy in the frequency of sex....

 

None of these, by themselves, are an indication of lacking in love but, because of that widely held belief, many people have sex out of fear and guilt rather than out of desire. That will surely end up undermining love, in the end.

sighsnootles's picture

sighsnootles

image

i love my husband like crazy,

i love my husband like crazy, and i dont' want to have sex with him all the time...  sometimes a cuddle or just to be held is what i need.  if he makes a pass at me then, i'm like 'ewwwwwwww!!!!'

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

Ohmigosh !!!! I just had a

Ohmigosh !!!!

I just had a visual of dat

sighsnootles's picture

sighsnootles

image

sorry about that, jess... my

sorry about that, jess... my husband is a marathon runner, so its only me that you need to visualize as 'less than hot'....

 

hope that mends at least some of the damage...

She_Devil's picture

She_Devil

image

This feels like a huge

This feels like a huge generalization to me, She_Devil

 

It is a generalization.   Women's bodies go through so many things guys don't have a clue about like pregnancy, miscarriage, childbirth, menopause, etc.   For me I have had no desire for sex since about the seventh month of my pregnancy.  (that is what got me into this situation)  I am so happy my husband is sleeping in the basement.   I cannot believe that he would WANT sex at this point but it is not his body that is changing.  I should rephrase the generalization so it is a bit more accurate.  I think that if a person is not interested in sex that is a problem.  A person may not be up to doing sex for phsysical reasons.

She_Devil's picture

She_Devil

image

sighsnootles wrote: sorry

sighsnootles wrote:

sorry about that, jess... my husband is a marathon runner, so its only me that you need to visualize as 'less than hot'....

 

hope that mends at least some of the damage...

 

we can't visualize you as hot or less than hot because we are straight.  we may need some help in that regard from stevieg

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

Ya don't wanna be too hot

Ya don't wanna be too hot .... the really hot women are supposed to be duds in the sack

Satyagraha's picture

Satyagraha

image

  A psychologically balanced

  A psychologically balanced (normal) & mature person will not be interested in a caring &  intimate relationship with someone who uses or otherwise disrespects them.  Too many people mistake sex  for love. 

  A person can have all the sex she wants, with or without love.  There are different kinds of love, but the kind of love being discussed here is the kind usually experienced between two adults in a sexual relationship.  In a respectful & intimate relationship between two mature (intellectually & emotionally mature, not old) adults, sex is very important & can still be part of the relationship even into old age, because sex is not just about pleasing yourself physically but is more about expressing your love & caring for your partner in a real & intimate way.  The selfishness which is inherent in a purely sexual "relationship" is replaced with selflessness & giving in a real relationship between two people who truly love one another, so the sex in such a relationship is far better & more intense (it should be, anyway).

  True love is about the willingness of each person in the relationship to extend oneself to help the other in a truly caring manner, not just in sex, but in all aspects of the relationship.  If the other person uses you or shows contempt or disrespect in some other way to you over a long period of time, that person does not love you, because with respect there is no love.  That doesn't mean everything will be blissful & peaceful & perfect.  In fact, one real sign of respect is the willingness of the other person to challenge you to improve yourself & provide gentle but constructive criticism, when necessary. 

  Sex can exist without love, but love (between two mature adults in their sexually active years) without sex is almost impossible in a loving intimate relationship.

 

 

   

generic guy's picture

generic guy

image

Sex is more important to me

Sex is more important to me than a long-term relationship. That may change as I get older, I don't really know, but right now, I am not interested in a love relationship. I like romance like anyone else, but I just wouldn't want it to get too serious.  Sex is just sex.  It is gratifying and mutually pleasurable.  I don't know why we pretend it is so special.

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

LOL what a mechanical answer

LOL what a mechanical answer Besh ...

Yes it's a connection

No it does not have to be an emotional one all the time

 

generic guy's picture

generic guy

image

Yes, I suppose I have a

Yes, I suppose I have a completely biased view of sex.  So do you.

MorningCalm's picture

MorningCalm

image

Love trumps all.

Love trumps all.

MorningCalm's picture

MorningCalm

image

jesouhaite777 wrote: LOL it's

jesouhaite777 wrote:

LOL it's the boys that do da chasing most of the time.

 

Not in our relationship. My Yobo chased me from before the time I first met her.

 

She actually came to my church with her best friend who was a church member. She scoped out all the single guys she saw, but none excited her. Then... she saw me. It was love at first sight.

 

A few months later we met, and she wasn't really my type. She never let up, though. The emails, the phone calls, the visits to my church, etc. Eventually I did start having deep feelings of love for her. It was a much more gradual thing for me though than it had been for her.

 

That's my story, and I'm sticking with it.

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

LOL she must be the rare

LOL she must be the rare exception to the rule

13Stories's picture

13Stories

image

I think that love and sex

I think that love and sex both important. I don't know if I would say that I feel the same way that she-devil does with the thought " If you love someone you will want to have sex with them." I love my parner but I don't have the sex drive that he does at all. He is the type that would like too all the time. Myself, on the other hand would be happy with every cupple of weeks.  Because we love each other we can compromize.

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

 Because we love each other

 Because we love each other we can compromize.

Sorry sweetie that won't work forever ..................

Serena's picture

Serena

image

I don't know.  I think it

I don't know.  I think it would depend on the situation.   I know of people who are having open affairs because their spouse has alzheimers and is not in a position to be a spouse but they do not divorce.

 

I think men are more liklely to stray than women.  Maybe men think they need more sex.  I think for men sex is more mechanical and for women sex is more spiritual and you have to care on some level about the person.  So that would make a difference too.

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

Oh women stray too just who

Oh women stray too just who do you think the dudes are cheating with ?

women sex is more spiritual

yeah those web cam girls are asking for spiritual direction on their knees ......

Serena's picture

Serena

image

jes wrote:yeah those web cam

jes wrote:
yeah those web cam girls are asking for spiritual direction on their knees ......

 

It is called the gathering.   So when girls are on their knees its a threesome or a foursome.  Very spiritual.

Kappa's picture

Kappa

image

To answer the original

To answer the original question, no, at least not for me.  I believe both are probably important to most people and some people keep them separate. When I think of Love, I also don't think only of Romantic Love in the modern Western sense, but of caring, bonding, and sharing with others. I don't expect to have just one love relationship, but for practical and emotional reasons, one sexual relationship at a time is definitely best for me.

MorningCalm's picture

MorningCalm

image

Chocolate chip cookies are

Chocolate chip cookies are most important of all. Especially with milk.

MistsOfSpring's picture

MistsOfSpring

image

At many times in my adulthood

At many times in my adulthood I've lived without sex.  It's not ideal, but it's survivable.  Without love, however, I think I'd shrivel up and die. 

southpaw's picture

southpaw

image

My ex-wife, a teacher, would

My ex-wife, a teacher, would give me a verbal 'report card' of my 'performance' after each 'romp'.  I told her if the work wasn't satisfactory, I'd have to keep doing it over and over again until I got it right.  All of a sudden, I was getting better 'reports'.  She was task oriented.  I was people oriented.  LIke mixing oil and water, .....but somehow we had two kids.

Back to Relationships topics