In the last month, I have noticed at least 4 posters who tell their stories or a close friends story and Suicide has been mentioned. They all seem to be young people and I am wondering just how big of a problem this is in our society .
More now than in earlier years, less or the same? What do you think and what is the answer?
© WonderCafe. All Rights Reserved
Brought to you by the people of The United Church of Canada
Opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of WonderCafe or The United Church of Canada
Comments
sighsnootles
its the same, its just that
Posted on: 05/06/2009 10:47
its the same, its just that now we are a part of the global village here, we hear about it more.
blackbelt
Actually it’s
Posted on: 05/06/2009 12:36
Actually it’s a big problem, a friend of mine works for TTC, i am told there is one to two suicides weekly , a relative of mine , going back a few yrs , committed suicide by lying on the tracks and currently by brother in law is working in the tunnles in downtown Toronto, he told me the same thing.
My pastor did a sermon on this one Sunday, he said that there have been studies done on this and it was discovered that the number one future killer disease is not heart attacks or cancers but depression , I tend to believe it, we are the most materialistic well off people him history, yet we are the most indebted people in history , while some are very rich, most are very poor and the middle class slowly being wiped out. With all our advanced techno today , we are the most drug induced , medicated people that ever lived on this planet, yet studies show our generation has the highest suicide rate.
What’s going on?
crazyheart
blackbelt, the global village
Posted on: 05/06/2009 12:48
blackbelt, the global village that sigh refers to, is that escalating the problem and are we becoming insensitive to it?
blackbelt
crazyheart wrote: blackbelt,
Posted on: 05/06/2009 12:59
blackbelt, the global village that sigh refers to, is that escalating the problem and are we becoming insensitive to it?
ok, excuse me, my command of english is not the best, so global village meens the problem is esaclating?
Birthstone
stress, demands of society,
Posted on: 05/06/2009 13:09
stress, demands of society, expectations of family, alcoholism - I'm not sure if the problem is larger or just obvious when it happens, but somehow we need to give people the freedom to be imperfect without shame.
crazyheart
No, I am not saying it is
Posted on: 05/06/2009 13:18
No, I am not saying it is escalating because of the Global Village, I am asking "Do you think it is?"
Yes, Birthstone.
blackbelt
crazyheart wrote: No, I am
Posted on: 05/06/2009 13:21
No, I am not saying it is escalating because of the Global Village, I am asking "Do you think it is?"
Yes, Birthstone.
ha, yes i do
claudia
well I feel like comitting
Posted on: 05/06/2009 14:50
well I feel like comitting suicide sometimes
claudia
i feel lonely it's so
Posted on: 05/06/2009 14:51
i feel lonely it's so annoying...................i don't know what's eating me up
lastpointe
Hi Claudia, I just added to
Posted on: 05/06/2009 15:07
Hi Claudia,
I just added to your parenting thread. I really hope you will see your doctor. Feeling suicidal sometimes , especially after you have had a baby is something that you can get lots of help for.
Please call your doctor, today and see him tomorrow.
lastpointe
I am not sure if we have more
Posted on: 05/06/2009 15:09
I am not sure if we have more suicide or if we are more open about it. In the past it was such a taboo subject. The Catholic church would not bury you in the cemetery (do they still have that rule) and people were embarrassed to talk about it. Just like they were embarrassed to talk about any mental illness.
As Nuclear families i think we have lost alot of the built in supports that our parents had. Families living in the same hourse or on the same block. Sharing of the work and the debt and the worries.
Many people now feel so alone and helpless.
SG
I agree with lastpointe. The
Posted on: 05/06/2009 15:19
I agree with lastpointe. The suicides of even our recent past were not reported as suicides. My wife found out about a suicide in her family tree, as did I , only through doing the genealogy. Each family never spoke of it.
puppypaws
I think that is escalating at
Posted on: 05/06/2009 16:18
I think that is escalating at least from what I have seen in my 17 years. I think the problem is that todays society has become so brutally mean to all of those that don't fit in which makes them feel like they have no reason to live. As well alot of parents put so much pressure on their kids to be perfect that sometimes they just want to do something that isn't expected (but this usually is cutting not suicide). And cutting well that is just a whole nother game altogether and also a problem that I think people would be surprised to learn is much bigger then it seems and effects a lot more people then you might think it is just easy for people to hide it.... but I won't get into that.
I have to say though I can almost guarantee that almost every teen these days contemplates suicide at least once. Our society has put so much pressure on us that sometimes we feel like we just have no other place to turn. I don't think the answer is to just always say suicide is wrong or not the answer. All though this is true when someone is contemplating sucicide these are pointless useless words to them.
Trust me I was told this many times in fact IRONY I went to a Safetalk workshop (how to talk people out of suicide) at my school at the time when I myself was thinking of commiting suicide. It did nothing!! People don't want to commit suicide they just feel like there is no other choice I think the key is to show them that there is something more to life and to accept them for who they are.... we must stop judging these people and telling them they are horrible people for thinking what they do. That is not what they need to hear...they just need to be loved.... I know at least that is the only thing that helped me.
And birthstone I think what you said about how "we need to give people the freedom to be imperfect without shame." Is the key to lowering suicide rates.
So the answer to this problem is to love people for who they are and to stop being so judmental... problem is I don't think society is ever going to get better in this are only worse.... sadly I only see suicide rates rising even more unless society makes a huge turnaround in our views of the world aaround us and the way we treat our fellow human beings.
seeler
It's not a new problem.
Posted on: 05/06/2009 18:20
It's not a new problem. Eighty years or so ago (long before I was born) my father's sister (late teens, early 20s) was found dead with my father's hunting rifle lying on the floor beside her. My father couldn't understand how that rifle had fallen from the gun rack on the wall and gone off - especially when he was sure he never put it away without unloading it. Surely someone had come into the house and murdered her. But the official versiou of her death was 'accidental'. I don't think they ever considered suicide.
When I was a young person I often had thoughts of suicide - never to the point where I made a plan, but enough that realizing that I was thinking about it scared me. My sister once threatened suicide. (Life wasn't good at home after our mother died.) Either life got better or I outgrew the stage. I don't know the stats but I think that suicide is more prevalent among the young. Today I can't imagine doing anything to hurry the process of dying. Also I think suicide would be a terrible thing to do when I have children and grandchildren who would bear the effects of it.
Is it worse now than it was years ago? I don't know the stats - or the estimates of how many might be, or have been, covered up. I think it gets worse among the young when they see no hope for the future. Maybe in tough economic times the rates will go up. Maybe when people see real choices ahead of them, and can make plans for the future the rates go down.
Suicide among the elderly is probably a different matter altogether. Probably many, like Margaret Laurence, just hurry death along a bit. I think I'll fight it to the end - but I'm not in that place yet.
carolla
Stats Canada info indicates
Posted on: 05/07/2009 23:44
Stats Canada info indicates that the overall suicide rate 2001 - 2005 (most recent available data) is quite stable - approx 11 per 100,000. I do agree that we seem to hear more about it though, and that does make many of us worry, for sure.
I was interested to hear puppypaws mention the SafeTALK event at his school - it's a programme delivered by trainers through an organization called Living Works (www.livingworks.net) They teach various levels of intervention strategies for suicide "first aid" - i.e. what you might say or do in the moment, how to ask people if they're thinking about suicide etc. Just as CPR training has become more widely known in the public - so too could the public learn about suicide intervention strategies. Perhaps its something churches could address? Particularly in these tougher economic times ....
ninjafaery
Great link Carolla. I'm
Posted on: 05/08/2009 11:09
Great link Carolla. I'm going to look into it. This intervention program emphasizes the importance of talking freely about suicide vs treating like it's taboo.
I agree.
carolla
Just curious then - has
Posted on: 05/19/2009 17:52
Just curious then - has anyone's church done any proactive suicide prevention programmes? Has such a thing ever been thought about or discussed? Or is it still largely under wraps of stigma? Some churches support AA programmes, weight-watchers, ... would such a thing be so out of line?
crazyheart
i don't want to make light of
Posted on: 05/19/2009 22:59
i don't want to make light of this because it is a serious problem. But when kids use this threat is it a new pop culture thing when they are writing blogs and on message boards etc.
puppypaws
crazyheart wrote: i don't
Posted on: 05/20/2009 22:01
i don't want to make light of this because it is a serious problem. But when kids use this threat is it a new pop culture thing when they are writing blogs and on message boards etc.
I would have to say no crazyheart. I think it is just that life is getting tougher for teens therefore making more of us suseptable to this feeling.
Kappa
That said, a greater degree
Posted on: 05/21/2009 21:24
That said, a greater degree of exposure to suicide is a risk factor for suicide. But I think puppypaws you have hit the nail on the head when you say that people who think about suicide are thinking about it because their options seem limited and completely hopeless. That's why phones on bridges work: they wouldn't work if people were really bent on dying, because then no one would call the help lines. I think young people (adolescents) are at such high risk because everything seems so much more important when you are young, and we often don't have much experience of how things can be different.
I think talking freely about suicidal thoughts and what they mean is important...suicide is still kept quiet in the media because of the known "copycat" phenomenon (Kurt Cobain was a good example of this).
Ergo Ratio
Unless there has been a spike
Posted on: 05/28/2009 03:34
Unless there has been a spike in the past five years, suicide rates are lower than they were in the 90s. You just hear about it more on internet forums, especially those where people turn to for emotional support.
http://www.socialreport.msd.govt.nz/health/suicide.html
waterfall
With so many posters
Posted on: 05/28/2009 10:10
With so many posters suggesting suicide, did we ever get a link on the website for suicide prevention?