Are we colour Blind in Church?

I read this yesterday and we don't sing it in church much any more.

 

Jesus loves the little chilren

All the children in the world,

red and yellow, black and white,

They are precious in his sight,

Jesus loves the little children in the world.

 

I don't think it would  relate much to the people in the church I  went to. No black children, no First Nations children, no Asian children - only white anglo saxon, middle class ( and very few of them) in the pews.

 

I don't know where this thread will go but I am throwing it out to ask what you see in your church pews? Are we colour blind in our churches or are  some of us making a conscious effort to keep colour out?

Comments

I doubt there is a plan to

I doubt there is a plan to keep out th people of different colors.  Why would a congregation need a plan?  Local people of different color already know they aren't welcome as an equal.

Kay I am assuming that you ae

Kay I am assuming that you ae speaking for yourself and not every one else. We are a predominantly white community that doesn't stop other races from worshipping with us we have many different colored people that join us at church, They are welcome and very active members of our congregation.

People of foreign culture,

People of foreign culture, especially those who are rather new to our culture, are seperated by our culture because of the differences, so it is up to the church to accomidate a body of believers who are dealing with the cultural differences in our scociety.

 

It must be a huge challenge for those who come to Canada from places who believe different ways, & the scociety fro where the came is so different.

 

This "accomidating" is regularly done by the sharing of a church facilties to accomidate a community of believers who have cultural differences in launguage & traditions etc. within their culture.

 

 

Bolt

Sorry musicsooths, I was

Sorry musicsooths, I was referring to the churches I'm familiar with in my own small town, and those I have been familiar with in other places. 

Bolt, I agree. That it must

Bolt, I agree. That it must be very lonely for these folk. Away from friends and family, most are learning a new language. There must be a way to make a conscious effort to invite them. A Korean family joined the church and they were lovely people. We learned so much from them. But it was our loss when they decided to start a church for other Korean folk in the city.

Maybe it starts with the

Maybe it starts with the pastor .... with a certain mentality

 

If you let one in then you have to let all in ....

here is a scenario

you're a dashing middle aged pastor working in a medium sized community

your congregation is at least 3 generations thick and you have been there for at least 20 or more years

 

life is good ........your members are very easy to get along with................. some of them give you personal notes of thanks , others bring fresh veggies from their home gardens ... they love your quaint little sermons and your dreamy shimmering blue eyes

 

you get a letter from the mother church asking you to reach out to a new immigrant community ...... so you decide to have a little cultural get to know each other ...... and several families show up

 

you feel like you've opened up a can of worms you have no way to relate to these people

your upper middle class life is no match for their lives, being terrorized by some despot or eating mudcakes as a child or having cattle prods attached to your weenie during the civil war ....

 

 

your best experience with other cultures is when your parents hired some dude called Pablo to build a deck at your house .......

 

your new members are not passive, since they are part of "The Struggle" they are very vocal and are not impressed by your quaint sermons , and shimmering blue eyes . you feel over matched , exposed , even the members of your old congregation are starting to wonder.

 

pretty soon your superiors start getting complaints from the new members ...... that they want their own pastor from their own cultural background who can understand their trials and tribulations .....

 

to avoid a bigger can of worms the mother church decides to give in to their demands and they get a pastor that they like and you get banished to some quaint fishing town ......

 

better to play it safe .....

 

crazyheart wrote: I read this

crazyheart wrote:

I read this yesterday and we don't sing it in church much any more.

 

Jesus loves the little chilren

All the children in the world,

red and yellow, black and white,

They are precious in his sight,

Jesus loves the little children in the world.

 

First, the song has been revised. The third line now goes, "red, brown, yellow, black, and white."

 

Quote:
I don't think it would  relate much to the people in the church I  went to. No black children, no First Nations children, no Asian children - only white anglo saxon, middle class ( and very few of them) in the pews.

 

We have black people including children, asian people including children, brown people, white people including children, and some of mixed race. 

 

Quote:
I don't know where this thread will go but I am throwing it out to ask what you see in your church pews? Are we colour blind in our churches or are  some of us making a conscious effort to keep colour out?

 

At our church we are colour blind.

crazyheart wrote: Bolt, I

crazyheart wrote:

Bolt, I agree. That it must be very lonely for these folk. Away from friends and family, most are learning a new language. There must be a way to make a conscious effort to invite them. A Korean family joined the church and they were lovely people. We learned so much from them. But it was our loss when they decided to start a church for other Korean folk in the city.

 

We have several Korean families at my church. From my own experience, however, many Koreans prefer to worship at Korean churches. While I go to a multi-ethnic Baptist church, my wife attends a Korean Presbyterian one.

crazyheart wrote: Bolt, I

crazyheart wrote:

Bolt, I agree. That it must be very lonely for these folk. Away from friends and family, most are learning a new language. There must be a way to make a conscious effort to invite them. A Korean family joined the church and they were lovely people. We learned so much from them. But it was our loss when they decided to start a church for other Korean folk in the city.

 

Well, can't we associate the same principle to the GLBT community?

Have we not done so already?

 

For us to look at Paul's teaching, like we do with the Old testament law, what will we find?

Error?

Even Paul said He wasn't perfect but is perfected in Christ our Lord.

Even Paul said He had to die daily.

 

Let's look at the words spoken by Jesus in referance.  Let's look deep.

Is there error? Can anyone say there is error in the Christ conscience?

 

Not I.

 

 

 

Bolt

boltupright wrote: crazyheart

boltupright wrote:

crazyheart wrote:

Bolt, I agree. That it must be very lonely for these folk. Away from friends and family, most are learning a new language. There must be a way to make a conscious effort to invite them. A Korean family joined the church and they were lovely people. We learned so much from them. But it was our loss when they decided to start a church for other Korean folk in the city.

 

Well, can't we associate the same principle to the GLBT community?

 

I was not aware the GLBT community was learning a new language.

 

Are you proposing they start their own churches...?

match3frog.

match3frog. wrote:

boltupright wrote:

crazyheart wrote:

Bolt, I agree. That it must be very lonely for these folk. Away from friends and family, most are learning a new language. There must be a way to make a conscious effort to invite them. A Korean family joined the church and they were lovely people. We learned so much from them. But it was our loss when they decided to start a church for other Korean folk in the city.

 

Well, can't we associate the same principle to the GLBT community?

 

I was not aware the GLBT community was learning a new language.

 

Are you proposing they start their own churches...?

I'm not proposing anything, just opening doors of discussion.

 

Who is to say they do speak the same launguage?

If they feel rejected, do they feel the same pain as we do?

Then why would representantives of  Christ inflict pain on those without understanding, & then profess to have understanding?

 

When all the while they have absoultely no concept of the launguage they speak out of pain.

How do those who feel they have no pain anymore, relate to those they may have hurt.?

 

A lack of understanding each other is the same as speaking English to one who only understands Hebrew. or Greek.

 

I propose a personal relationship with Jesus the Christ if anything.

 

The Spirit of God is multi-cultural, among many many other things.

 

 

Bolt

There are very few churches

There are very few churches in my area that have mixed race congregations.  The ones that do tend to be Baptist and Catholic.  Most of the United and Anglican Churches are mostly if not exclusively white.  That's on the Dartmouth side, I'm not sure about Halifax.

Poeple naturally segragate

Poeple naturally segragate themselves to some degree, & it doen't have to be race, obviously.

This is something that comes natural to us, due only to our insecurities & ignorance.

 

 

Bolt

Most churches represent the

Most churches represent the context they find themselves in - one congregation had several native canadians- current has asian - the larger city one had blacks - in prop to the community and history.

  My pastor this Sunday

 

My pastor this Sunday morning during service announced that our church is representative of 30 cultures, I so love the diversity .  

 match3frog said: "At our

 match3frog said:

"At our church we are colour blind."

_______________________________________________________________________

I don't know who you are match3frog, but in the spirit of engaging with each other critically and in love I will say that this statement is of deep concern.  I hope you aren't colour blind at your church.  Being colour blind is a serious problem in churches.  Those who are colour blind refuse to acknowledge the cultures of others and that we're not all white.  

Somebody being "colour blind" would make me question their integrity.

kilnerad wrote: I don't know

kilnerad wrote:

I don't know who you are match3frog, but in the spirit of engaging with each other critically and in love I will say that this statement is of deep concern.  I hope you aren't colour blind at your church.  Being colour blind is a serious problem in churches.  Those who are colour blind refuse to acknowledge the cultures of others and that we're not all white.  

Somebody being "colour blind" would make me question their integrity.

 

What I mean, kilnerad, is simply this: all have equal opportunities in the church regardless of race. Something wrong with that?

 

You can lay no accusation of not appreciating other cultures on me. My own family is multicultural, and I have deep appreciation and love for the culture of my wife and stepson.

 No accusation is being made

 No accusation is being made here.  I'm sorry you feel accused.

 

In many congregations I have been in there is no truth to the statement that "all have equal opportunities in the church regardless of race" because in mainline congregations it is rare that worship and small groups are based on non-white cultural norms.

Unless, of course you include denominations like the African Methodist Episcopal Church, African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, British Methodist Episcopal Church, National Baptist Convention, the Church of God in Christ, Coptic Orthodox Church, etc. or other individual non-white congregations within other denominations.

kilnerad wrote:  No

kilnerad wrote:

 No accusation is being made here.  I'm sorry you feel accused.

 

In many congregations I have been in there is no truth to the statement that "all have equal opportunities in the church regardless of race" because in mainline congregations it is rare that worship and small groups are based on non-white cultural norms.

well then , you should come to my church and see that your "no truth" is no truth at all

I must say that in my

I must say that in my previous church for many years we had an active family from Trinidad.  When the girls grew up the family moved away and we were mainly white anglo-saxon for many years.  Recently they have welcomed some Korean families. 

 

The church I attend now is also predominately white anglo-saxon, but it is a large church and has a board mix of others:   quite a large number of French families (one or both parents French and often RC but attending the UCC); people from other European countries; from Cuba; from Africa; or from Korea.  They participate in worship and other parts of church life to the extend they are interested - some in Sunday School, some on the official board, some in the choir - the same as everybody else.  We benefit from the diversity.

kilnerad wrote:Unless, of

kilnerad wrote:
Unless, of course you include denominations like the African Methodist Episcopal Church, African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, British Methodist Episcopal Church, National Baptist Convention, the Church of God in Christ, Coptic Orthodox Church, etc. or other individual non-white congregations within other denominations.

 

At our church we seek to follow God's Word, honoring people of all races equally. It is our goal to worship God, learn about Him, serve God and others, and tell people about Jesus. We do not exist to promote any race above any other.

 match3frog: How does your

 match3frog:

How does your congregation honour other "races"?  Are there liturgical elements, other languages, or cultural traditions implemented into worship and church life?

kilnerad

kilnerad wrote:

 match3frog:

How does your congregation honour other "races"?  Are there liturgical elements, other languages, or cultural traditions implemented into worship and church life?

are you kidding,

everybody is equle under the Lord

kilnerad brings up a very

kilnerad brings up a very valuable point. One worth looking at for those who say their aim is equality. When people say colour blind, they may also not truly honour or value differences (asimilation or homogenization). Correct?

 

Sunday, during church service hours, are the most segregated hours. There has to be intentionality and talking about it, before it can be lived out in relationships or facilitated.

 

Does your church bring in other words, other ways of worshipping, other cultural stuff? What of the various expressions of worship?

 

What about art? What does Jesus look like in your church?

 

What about music? Do you sing hymns from many traditions?

 

To me, simply saying it is like saying you are affirming when the language is "male and female", "husband and wife", "man and woman", "father and mother" etc... Saying we are all equal does not cut it without all being represented or fully embraced even in their absence.

 

How would your church respond to someone worshipping differently? People worship sometimes in culturally distinct ways. I sway/rock when I pray or speak of God (from aJewish background)... people were taken aback by it and/or thought it was nervousness. What about an "Amen"? How about dancing or clapping during hymns?

 

I went to an Easter liturgy once that read from the Bible in every language represented by a congregant. It was beautiful. I also know that coming from a Jewish background, I watch Seder suppers Christianized. You cannot be what you claim you are sometimes without intentionality.

 

here is the true church

here is the true church

 Blackbelt wrote: are you

 Blackbelt wrote:

are you kidding,

everybody is equle under the Lord

_________________________________________________

Examples....

 

____________________________

 

Thanks for the video!!!

kilnerad wrote:  Blackbelt

kilnerad wrote:

 Blackbelt wrote:

 

 

are you kidding,

everybody is equle under the Lord

_________________________________________________

Examples....

 

____________________________

 

Thanks for the video!!!

 

 

you just got one

 

 

 

 

 

blackbelt]</p> <p>[quote=kiln

blackbelt]</p> <p>[quote=kilnerad wrote:

 are you kidding,

everybody is equle under the Lord

 

Exactly, thank you brother, well said.

A few examples I can give

A few examples I can give that I have heard at one time or another during worship:

 

Singing a hymn in a language other than English - either one verse or the entire hymn

Singing a familiar hymn to a different tune and type of music while using drums or other instruments not usual in Anglo-Saxon worship

Scripture read in a language other than English by a speaker of that language.  I heard the 23rd Psalm read in Dutch.

Eash verse of the 23rd psalm read in a different language by different people familiar with that language.  (It was also printed in the bulletin with the different languages identified).

Having a Spanish speaking Cuban visitor lead in prayer with another person translating.    And on another occasion in Korean.

Learning the Lord's Prayer in French.

Having a person 'sign' a scripture reading or hymn - and teaching the children how to 'sign'.

In Sunday School children may be encouraged to teach a few words of their first language, talk about different customs in their homes, bring pictures of relatives and scenery from their homeland (or their parents or grandparents homeland), and talk about visits to foreign lands.

 

Youth might learn the Salsa dance, eat food brought in by a student from another culture, listen to music from another culture.  If the church is big enough, or has a large enough population, they might have a Latin night, or a Bobby Burns night.

 

seeler, I love the ideas. Our

seeler, I love the ideas. Our community is not all that diverse, though we have identified that we need to present that the world is and teach some diversity inside church.

DKS

DKS

image

kilnerad wrote:  No

kilnerad wrote:

 No accusation is being made here.  I'm sorry you feel accused.

 

In many congregations I have been in there is no truth to the statement that "all have equal opportunities in the church regardless of race" because in mainline congregations it is rare that worship and small groups are based on non-white cultural norms.

Unless, of course you include denominations like the African Methodist Episcopal Church, African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, British Methodist Episcopal Church, National Baptist Convention, the Church of God in Christ, Coptic Orthodox Church, etc. or other individual non-white congregations within other denominations.

 

 I dunno, Adam. We have a BME congregation around the corner from my church. I've worshipped with them and they with us. I found their service quite similar to our United Church service (but their singing was better). I shouldn't generalize on one congregaion, though.

We should be careful not to

We should be careful not to create schisms.

If we are ALL created in His

If we are ALL created in His Image, then the color of our skin makes little difference.

I believe, Christ conscience is about seeing Christ in us.

If we were to see the facial features of Jesus, could it corrupt us?

Would it form a bias?

 

Has not a bias been formed by the mere example of Christ being "flesh"?

Would & could we relate If we saw Jesus as a black man, if we are white?

I guess that depends on our Christ conscience.

 

Any division in this world is a result of our differences of each other, once we are enlightened to the fact the the flesh has very little to do with unity, the cultural differences will make little difference as well.

 

The cultural differences of the age when Christ walked here, are every bit as different to us,culturally,  as those who live today in tribe of peoples of the Amazon Forrest.

So cultural differences are no excuse

 

The Christ conscience is multi-cultural

 

 

Bolt

StevieG wrote:Does your

StevieG wrote:
Does your church bring in other words, other ways of worshipping, other cultural stuff? What of the various expressions of worship?

 

Why all the questions about my church. What about your church? We do sing in other languages at times. We welcome both quiet worshipping and more emotive.

 

Quote:
What about art? What does Jesus look like in your church?

 

Strange thing is he is usually depicted as being a Jewish man.

 

Quote:
What about music? Do you sing hymns from many traditions?

 

Yes. Indeed we have had people sing songs from their countries of origin in their own styles and languages.

 

Quote:
To me, simply saying it is like saying you are affirming when the language is "male and female", "husband and wife", "man and woman", "father and mother" etc... Saying we are all equal does not cut it without all being represented or fully embraced even in their absence.

 

Let's not get into the male/female thing here. We are discussing colour.

 

Quote:
How would your church respond to someone worshipping differently? People worship sometimes in culturally distinct ways. I sway/rock when I pray or speak of God (from aJewish background)... people were taken aback by it and/or thought it was nervousness. What about an "Amen"? How about dancing or clapping during hymns?

 

All fine at my church. I personally do not clap in church because I believe the worship service is to be directed to God not to humans.

whatever your name is I

whatever your name is

I was not specifically asking about your church. My comment was that IMO kilnerad had a point. It was one all who say equality is the goal could look at and it caused me to look at it with my own questions.

StevieG wrote: whatever your

StevieG wrote:

whatever your name is

I was not specifically asking about your church. My comment was that IMO kilnerad had a point. It was one all who say equality is the goal could look at and it caused me to look at it with my own questions.

 

Listen here, kilnerad was addressing me. You said he had made a good point then started asking a number of questions about "your" church. That implies me. I still await your answers to your questions.

I cannot say I ever recall

I cannot say I ever recall seeing artwork in any Christian church that represented Jesus looking anything but Anglo-Saxon white. 

 

He would not have looked like a European Jew either. He would have looked Semetic, Middle Eastern. Remember Judas had to point him out, he blended in with the people.

 

It makes me kind of giggle when I see flowing blond or light auburn or brown hair and the blue or hazel eyes.

StevieG wrote:It makes me

StevieG wrote:
It makes me kind of giggle when I see flowing blond or light auburn or brown hair and the blue or hazel eyes.

 

Here's a picture of Jesus that I like: http://www.nairaland.com/attachments/131190_Korean_Jesus_jpg6d034ffc7bc1000778c6bc12c4165e5e

The question was asked of you

The question was asked of you and I happened to think it could apply everywhere.

 

Don't "listen here' me. I am neither your child nor your wife. If you had been from Appalachia, I might accept a "listen here". In this case, I do not.

 

frog, it always amazes me

frog, it always amazes me that everything about your church is perfect - no exceptions except on Sunday when you said you had a fight over the music and left the service. ummmmm, maybe not so perfect.

StevieG wrote: The question

StevieG wrote:

The question was asked of you and I happened to think it could apply everywhere.

 

Don't "listen here' me. I am neither your child nor your wife. If you had been from Appalachia, I might accept a "listen here". In this case, I do not.

 

 

There is nothing reasonably objectionable about that phrase, unlike your own "whatever your name is"

crazyheart wrote: frog, it

crazyheart wrote:

frog, it always amazes me that everything about your church is perfect - no exceptions except on Sunday when you said you had a fight over the music and left the service. ummmmm, maybe not so perfect.

 

The only perfect thing about my church is it's head, Jesus Christ.

match3frog. wrote: crazyheart

match3frog. wrote:

crazyheart wrote:

frog, it always amazes me that everything about your church is perfect - no exceptions except on Sunday when you said you had a fight over the music and left the service. ummmmm, maybe not so perfect.

 

The only perfect thing about my church is it's head, Jesus Christ.

and a big AMEN ! to that

When I am speaking directly

When I am speaking directly to someone I make a habit of addressing it like an email with a name at the top. 

 

I had not done so, so I was not speaking to you.  In fact, I quite some time ago expressed my thoughts on the various names you have used and said that since it was no longer a suspicion and not an inkling or a rumour, but was proven... I could feel free to simply ignore you.

 

I do. You mistakenly thought I was addressing you and responded to that. I likely should have simply ignored that too. I however did not.

 

You thought I was speaking to you and yes I referred to you as "whatever your name is". It was not meant to be polite or warm and fuzzy. I do not have those feelings and will not pretend to. I do not respect you, I do not trust you and I do not like you.

 

If "whatever your name is" is objectionable to you then perhaps you should not have used so many various names and since you did perhaps you should have been honest about doing so when it was asked about and then later alleged.

 

If you can come up with something that does not make me part of the name game of yours then tell me what that salutation might be. For clarity, I still intend to ignore you, but should there be some miscommunication like above, it would provide a salutation perahps less objectionable to you.

 

If you come up with something that does not make me a pawn, complicant... then tell me what that salutation might be.
 

 

As we were addressing culture, "listen here" is objectionable to me. It is for many reasons. It is a way of telling someone to "shut up" and listen to me without having the guts to say so publicly or to try to look like a goodie-goodie while doing so. It has been and is used as a tool of domination and oppression. It has been used  to hush up women. It has been a tool used by people to shut up blacks. It has been a tool to shut up homosexuals.

 

I make exceptions when I know that "listen here" is part of another culture, like Appalachian people or some people of colour, who say "listen here" without that intent.

 

Your use of "listen here", coming from you.... unacceptable to me, period.

StevieG wrote: You thought I

StevieG wrote:

You thought I was speaking to you and yes I referred to you as "whatever your name is". It was not meant to be polite or warm and fuzzy. I do not have those feelings and will not pretend to. I do not respect you, I do not trust you and I do not like you.

 

and the typicle stevie shines through once more

Quote:


 

As we were addressing culture, "listen here" is objectionable to me. It is for many reasons. It is a way of telling someone to "shut up" and listen to me without having the guts to say so publicly or to try to look like a goodie-goodie while doing so. It has been and is used as a tool of domination and oppression. It has been used  to hush up women. It has been a tool used by people to shut up blacks. It has been a tool to shut up homosexuals.

 

 

 

you need help

When it comes to our church

When it comes to our church our Pastor is white; our Deacons are black, and white; our worship team is brown, white, and yellow; our Sunday School leaders are black, white, and yellow; our choir is white, and yellow; our outreach team is black, brown, white, and yellow; our Bible study teachers are white, and yellow. Seems pretty rainbowish to me. 

 

Normal 0

Normal 0 false false false EN-CA X-NONE X-NONE MicrosoftInternetExplorer4 matchfrog

 

only people with a personal agenda look to pic at things instead of looking to Jesus, not only in my church but also in life, i don't give a flying hoot of color, race , creed, I look at the heart and the heart alone, people who look to the skin and expect certin things because of the flavour of color that covers the bones in there bodies are shallow and spirtually blinded because they cannot see beyond , like Jesus saw, Souls

 

crazyheart wrote: I read this

crazyheart wrote:

I read this yesterday and we don't sing it in church much any more.

 

Jesus loves the little children

All the children in the world,

red and yellow, black and white,

They are precious in his sight,

Jesus loves the little children in the world.

I wonder if we avoid singing this in part because we would rather not acknowledge diversity, and then acknowledge the lack of diversity in our congregations (besides the issue of acknowledging whether we all believe that Jesus exists and loves... I won't go into that!).  I know that all the congregations I have been a part of have been almost 100% white.  In some places, that was representative of the surrounding community.  In other places, not so much.

 

Part of of our "colour blindness" is our inability to see how much of what we do and say reflects white North American culture, and not just the Christian story/tradition.  For myself, it is an ongoing journey to discover how I have been blind to the ways I have contributed to letting folks who are non-white, non-straight, non-middle class, etc, know that they outsiders.  And so I reflect, repent, and struggle to make change. 

 

shalom

blackbelt wrote:

blackbelt wrote:

Normal 0 false false false EN-CA X-NONE X-NONE MicrosoftInternetExplorer4 matchfrog
 

 

only people with a personal agenda look to pic at things instead of looking to Jesus, not only in my church but also in life, i don't give a flying hoot of color, race , creed, I look at the heart and the heart alone, people who look to the skin and expect certin things because of the flavour of color that covers the bones in there bodies are shallow and spirtually blinded because they cannot see beyond , like Jesus saw, Souls

 

 

I don't believe in loving and respecting people despite whatever race they are.

 

I believe in loving and respecting people because of whatever race they are. It is a beautiful part of what makes them them. 

I think the point that's

I think the point that's worth consideration is that, while people from other than European background may be in our congregations and the official policy is to make them welcome, if worship practices don't incorporate some elements of other cultures, then it makes it less likely that people who aren't from European background/cultures will feel welcome.

Back to Religion and Faith topics