Serena's picture

Serena

image

Sexism in the United Church

So I have come to the conclusion that the United Church is biased against men.   (not that that bothers me in the least   )   There were all these wonderful threads celebrating Mother's Day but no mention at all of Father's Day and Father's Day was today.

 

I guess fathers do not contribute anything worthwhile or valued by the Church.  

Share this

Comments

graeme's picture

graeme

image

Hey, that's okay. Women want

Hey, that's okay. Women want a mother's day? Let them have it. what the hell. We all know that God is our heavenly FATHER, and so we know which gender counts.

graeme

crazyheart's picture

crazyheart

image

Serena, Father's Day is next

Serena, Father's Day is next Sunday - 3rd Sunday in June, right?

Tyson's picture

Tyson

image

Actually, I believe father's

Actually, I believe father's day is on the 21st.

Pinga's picture

Pinga

image

Yup, father's day is june

Yup, father's day is june 21st....3rd sunday in June.

Pinga's picture

Pinga

image

though, honestly, it is a

though, honestly, it is a hallmark day.....as compared to a day to honour strong male role models.

InannaWhimsey's picture

InannaWhimsey

image

Father's Day will also be a

Father's Day will also be a Grand and Celebrated Wiccan Holy Day.

 

On that day, get OUT THERE, YOU CRAZYDIVINE Christians!

Get OUT THERE, YOU CRAZYDIVINE Pagans!

 

DANCE, and listen to the culmination of the Oak King and the Holly King fighting it out over the G_ddess. On Father's Day, the Oak King, finally defeated, becomes the Holly King, who reigns for half the year.

 

Just a Self-writing poem,

Inannawhimsey

Arminius's picture

Arminius

image

Pinga wrote: Yup, father's

Pinga wrote:

Yup, father's day is june 21st....3rd sunday in June.

 

Yes, Pinga, and I will celebrate it by uncorking a bottle of good red wine.

 

That's why the United Church does not celebrate fathers day: because of the "no alcohol" policy in United Church halls.

 

Cheers!

 

Arminius

 

Serena's picture

Serena

image

CH wrote: Serena, Father's

CH wrote:

Serena, Father's Day is next Sunday - 3rd Sunday in June, right? 

 

Hmmmm..... my class made their Father's Day gifts last Friday.   Mind you this week is busy.  On Monday we have a water fight.  On Wednesday we are gone all day for a field trip.  Thursday is Awards Day and the last day of School.  So it makes sense that we did our Father's Day gift last Friday.

 

So I guess I am a week ahead.     I thought we were later in June than we were.  

crazyheart's picture

crazyheart

image

hey Serena, don't worry. If I

hey Serena, don't worry. If I was looking after 5 kids this weekend I would forget my name let alone dates.

RevMatt's picture

RevMatt

image

Arminius wrote: That's why

Arminius wrote:

That's why the United Church does not celebrate fathers day: because of the "no alcohol" policy in United Church halls.

 

Psshh.  Some Congregations, maybe.  We have a wine and cheese in the sanctuary every year!

killer_rabbit79's picture

killer_rabbit79

image

Father's Day is huge where I

Father's Day is huge where I work. It's definitely on the 21st. Either way, what does the celebration (or lack thereof) of a nonreligious and nonstatutory holiday have to do with a church's biases and agendas?

Arminius's picture

Arminius

image

RevMatt wrote: Arminius

RevMatt wrote:

Arminius wrote:

That's why the United Church does not celebrate fathers day: because of the "no alcohol" policy in United Church halls.

 

Psshh.  Some Congregations, maybe.  We have a wine and cheese in the sanctuary every year!

 

Thanks, RevMatt, that's the ticket for Fathers Day! I'll put it before our Worship Committee and congregation for next year's Fathers Day. Too late for this year.

Arminius's picture

Arminius

image

killer_rabbit79

killer_rabbit79 wrote:

Father's Day is huge where I work. It's definitely on the 21st. Either way, what does the celebration (or lack thereof) of a nonreligious and nonstatutory holiday have to do with a church's biases and agendas?

 

Well, k.r., you have heard of "Father God," haven't you?

 

I celebrate Father God on Fathers Day, Mother God on Mothers Day, and IT every day.

Beloved's picture

Beloved

image

Greetings!   Phew . . . when

Greetings!

 

Phew . . . when I first read Serena's topic starter I thought "oh no, how did I miss it"?  Father's Day that is.

 

Nothing will take place at church, other than a possible mention of the day.  At home - we'll barbeque -and our one and only "father" will probably have a beer or two.

 

Hope, peace, joy, love ...

crazyheart's picture

crazyheart

image

Sounds like home, beloved.

Sounds like home, beloved.

Serena's picture

Serena

image

Dangit!!!!! There is no

Dangit!!!!! There is no sexism in the United Church.!!!!  

seeler's picture

seeler

image

Father's Day is not played

Father's Day is not played big in our church - often its the Sunday School picnic or we are recognizing the contribution of Native Peoples or promoting camping (a bit late for promoting, but there it is).  When I happen to be the guest worship leader, I follow the lectionary.  Father's day would be mentioned in the announcements - like congratulations to all Fathers and grandfathers.  Depending on the lectionary I might talk about it a bit with the children (touchy subject when the children come from many different types of families).  Or I will pray for fathers. 

 

My concern on Fathers Day is for the many men who are cut off from their children - perhaps that warrants a separate thread.

revjohn's picture

revjohn

image

Hi Serena,   Serena wrote: So

Hi Serena,

 

Serena wrote:

So I have come to the conclusion that the United Church is biased against men.   (not that that bothers me in the least   )   There were all these wonderful threads celebrating Mother's Day but no mention at all of Father's Day and Father's Day was today.

 

Maybe in Alberta.  In the rest of Canada Father's day is celebrated on the third sunday of June.

 

Grace and peace to you.

John

Elanorgold's picture

Elanorgold

image

Whew! You gave me a scare

Whew! You gave me a scare there! Thought I had missed it! Thanks for the reminder. Got to get a card out to Dad!

clergychickita's picture

clergychickita

image

In the United Church we

In the United Church we actually moved to celebrating "Christian Family Sunday" on Mother's Day, though many churches choose to focus on mothers instead.  So at least officially, there aren't any specifically mother or father days in the UCC.

shalom

seeler's picture

seeler

image

I've started a thread about

I've started a thread about Fathers Day in Parenting.  I invite you to check it out.

southpaw's picture

southpaw

image

My kids remember Father's day

My kids remember Father's day more than Mother's day.  (Their mother is extremely selfish, controlling and self-centered while I, on the other hand, am a fantastic dad.)      Humble, and proud of it!

southpaw's picture

southpaw

image

RevMatt wrote: Arminius

RevMatt wrote:

Arminius wrote:

That's why the United Church does not celebrate fathers day: because of the "no alcohol" policy in United Church halls.

 

Psshh.  Some Congregations, maybe.  We have a wine and cheese in the sanctuary every year!

I knew a church where they had a "whine" and cheese once a year.  It was called the annual meeting.

musicsooths's picture

musicsooths

image

LOL at Southpaw Sooooo true!

LOL at Southpaw Sooooo true!

Mendalla's picture

Mendalla

image

My UU church had a good

My UU church had a good proposal for a Father's Day service (basically a "sharing" service where various members would talk about their experience of being either fathers or children in place of a sermon). Unfortunately, the Worship Committee (which I was chairing) had already noted that it was Solstice on that Sunday and invited a couple of our pagan members to do a service on Solstice. So, the Dad's Day idea will be on the shelf until next year. We did have a pretty good Mother's Day service this year, though.

 

In my household, Dad's Day usually ends up being just another day although we may go out for dinner to celebrate.

 

Mendalla

 

RussP's picture

RussP

image

Mendalla   And usually I

Mendalla

 

And usually I don't even get to chose the restaurant

 

 

IT

 

Russ.

 

 

Mendalla's picture

Mendalla

image

RussP wrote: Mendalla   And

RussP wrote:

Mendalla

 

And usually I don't even get to chose the restaurant

 

 

IT

 

Russ.

 

 

 

We only have about 3-4 restaurants that we regularly patronize, so there's not much choosing to do. It's a matter of choosing a cuisine from Chinese, Viet-Thai, Japanese, or mixed buffet. So I generally get what I want by default .

 

Mendalla

 

PS. Don't want to make it sound like London is totally dead foodwise, but my wife and I aren't big on North American or European cuisine, and this isn't exactly the Asian food capital of Southern Ontario.

 

RussP's picture

RussP

image

Mendalla   Actually now that

Mendalla

 

Actually now that you mention it, I don't think my wife or I had any restaurant meals when we were at the Borg-In.

 

 

IT

 

Russ

WaterBuoy's picture

WaterBuoy

image

Whinei and cheezy? That's the

Whinei and cheezy? That's the way it has been ever since mother God gave father God that ribbing wah back when!

 

Omega Odd ... look what we've done ... something different!

 

IT could close up the church.

Charles T's picture

Charles T

image

Serena

Serena wrote:

Dangit!!!!! There is no sexism in the United Church.!!!!  

You could always get mad about the sexism in our culture.  Ever notice how the majority of males represnted in advertising or television shows are bumbling idiots continually being bailed out by their too sexy and smart for them wives?

The Liberal's picture

The Liberal

image

Charles T wrote: Serena

Charles T wrote:

Serena wrote:

Dangit!!!!! There is no sexism in the United Church.!!!!  

You could always get mad about the sexism in our culture.  Ever notice how the majority of males represnted in advertising or television shows are bumbling idiots continually being bailed out by their too sexy and smart for them wives?

 

But don't forget also to note that the majority of images of women on television looks nothing like real-life women do?  In other words, the regular dudes are being bailed out by aliens...

The_Omnissiah's picture

The_Omnissiah

image

The women on TV are

The women on TV are machines...and Machines are not to be trusted. 0.0

 

As-salaamu alaikum

-Omni

killer_rabbit79's picture

killer_rabbit79

image

This happens in sitcoms all

This happens in sitcoms all the time too. The men in Everybody Loves Raymond, According to Jim, and Married with Children, to name a few, are idiots, while the women are intelligent and hold the family together.

revjohn's picture

revjohn

image

Hi

Hi killer_rabbit79,

 

killer_rabbit79 wrote:

This happens in sitcoms all the time too. The men in Everybody Loves Raymond, According to Jim, and Married with Children, to name a few, are idiots, while the women are intelligent and hold the family together.

 

How intelligent can they really be considering who they ended up marrying?

 

Grace and peace to you.

John

WaterBuoy's picture

WaterBuoy

image

In old myth the soul and the

In old myth the soul and the spirit are both fey, flighty, bewitching essences ... ephemeral and able to get around anything that difficult ... like Pet Roues .. favourite decrees?

 If the soul and the spirit are father and mother of creation of the medium (physical manna of speak'n); do we each have a bit (chit, skett) of both in nous ... individuals just find ID hard to uncover without the face in the dirt? Perhaps this weeks litergy about the beauty and the beast is  a bit of the elite story of illum-m'n-ad-I ... the fire above. Ides enough to bring the house down when you read into IT the understanding and Love of I Corinthinans 13 and Acts 2:4 in Dan's time ... ain't that devilish timeless Ness, the dark shadow of the unacknowledged ... mind ... Zhi-Xi (sigh-key)?

 

How does one follow the aboriginal code for joining (let no man separate what God/Love has joined) when a Roman institution outlawed both Love and Intelligence in the Pagan world (common wee folk). Does the silent paradigm question such stuff or just sit arrested in fear when we are told so many times to fear not ... "id'll pas!" Gette IT/ID together ... here? There must be another space ... it stands to reason ... a Mir th' ought from nowhere ... nothing but me in (oui) carnal mode ... the general ad hock ... ignores! Is that root of d' Lucean meme? Yah have to read into the thing and not take isolated aspect!

Would a physical real m'n consider such myth? Unlike Liem a rare b'Ire'd ta tip! As Kant, a List, Mir tilde to the breeze! Ides ETs ... food for utilitarian ... the'o crossed ... Theo 'T ... aura's that the OX bleu'n? Bonne Yahn!

heretic's picture

heretic

image

http://www.abisource.com.

I do think that men may be treated unfairly in the church . I find that their are more women in the church than men and they are the majority . Event seem to cater to them . with few directed at men . In my church we have a men group and a Lady's group . why ? this is discriminatory in its self . my not a people group ? the church has a long way to go on treating people fairly . not just men and women but all minority in Canada . The population of the church dose not reflect the over all population diversity of Canada this alone tell you they treat people unfairly .

southpaw's picture

southpaw

image

Not just the church, but

Not just the church, but society seems bent on discriminating against men.  One young man applied for a police position only to be told, unofficially, they were targetting women and minorities.  (I TOLD him he should've wore a skirt.)  In the media, that annoying Cherrios commercial with the fake British accents where the husband is quieted because his wife thinks he's referring to her weight.  (shut up, Steve- she owned his wontons).  In many churches, men are staying away in droves because they think they're only there to do the 'donkey' work.  Anyone for starting up a No-M'am United Church for men only?  Free beer at every council meeting!  Paid for by the mission fund.

GordW's picture

GordW

image

Sexism in the church?  Alive

Sexism in the church?  Alive and well.

 

Studies of compensation routinely show that female people in paid accountable ministry are paid less and are more likely to be in part-time ministry than their male counterparts.

 

Sexism still cut both ways

WaterBuoy's picture

WaterBuoy

image

Is it any wonder that m'n in

Is it any wonder that m'n in Heb is translated in one ambiguity as an isolated gift of grace ... perhaps because he couln't get it all together? Island mentality! Is there autonomous reflex to such actions ... echos? That's canon in some definitions ... Big Bang across the vale ... veil of d' void? Ides just wool over Amen's eyes as he withdraws without a care into the darkness ... militant creature without thought of co operation!

What works in the animal world isn't necessarily satifactory in dimension of the mind ... "Feed my Lam!" Is a deep expression of which undersstanding is lost to the ignorance of mankind! Internalized Love is a shadowy margin ... media of the Wahl? Bones of the veil will rise again --- was that Eli Jah? (Light hand of God) is like a whisper well distributed over the fabric (covenant)!

The Liberal's picture

The Liberal

image

Maybe the scales have to

Maybe the scales have to swing the other way for just a little bit?  I hate to rain on your parade but the examples of discrimination against men given here... well, they don't compare to the thousands of years that women spent serving, being raped by, being owned by, being abused by men... and that's only the tip of the iceberg...  Look at our social structures: who makes all or most of the money?  Who is in nearly all the powerful positions?  Who runs the corporations?  Governments? 

 

I could go on but I don't really want to.  Sexism is very alive and very well indeed, and mostly, in the very serious and important ways, in favour of men.  Women continue to make 0.7$ on a man's dollar.  Women continue to fill service and cleaning and nursing positions.  Women continue to experience domestic violence and to fill shelters.  And women continue to be dependent on men for support and livelihood during their childbearing years (that $100 per child under age 6 from Harper really is a joke)... 

 

Actually's picture

Actually

image

This post was awesome.

This post was awesome.

Actually's picture

Actually

image

P.s.   it's hard to say if

P.s.   it's hard to say if sexism will ever die.   All I know is that when I worked as a pizza delivery girl, I always made more tips than my male counterparts, and now that I work in technical support, I can't count on my fingers and toes how many people tell me 'no... I want the technical support'  even after I assure them, yes, I am in technical support.   The boobs don't get in the way of me clearing your cache and cookies.  Mmm cookies.

The Liberal's picture

The Liberal

image

Hey, Actually... (sounds like

Hey, Actually...

(sounds like I'm about to argue, but no...)

 

Yeah, women do get more tips mostly in circumstances where some dudes can let their imaginations run free a little...  As you say, not that likely in computer tech support... unless you were called to show up at their door... preferably in a short skirt and low cut shirt.   That's sexism in action for you.
 

(Thinking about some of these things just makes me mad as hell.  Some will say, another freakin' femini-nazi.   But it's not just my jaded "opinion" of men - unfortunately, like many many women around me, there is some rather harsh life experience behind my feeling.  Here's one example:  I applied for a job once, was hired and invited for drinks afterward, agreed because why not, but when my new "boss" accidently-on-purpose stuck his hand between my legs at the bar, let's just say, I changed my mind about my new "position" with his company. Yes, these things do happen, still, today, now.)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Actually's picture

Actually

image

Gross!   Agnieszka!    I ,

Gross!   Agnieszka!   

I , and probably 90% of the women out there have had a similar experience.   I've had a male boss try to massage my shoulders when I was a waiter, I have had an outward full chest grope from a coworker when I did farming as a teen, and I have had a married man (a supervisor) follow me home from work and call my home to ask me out before.  (this last incident was reported, but work said they couldnt do anything about it because there was no proof he got my phone number from work).  I ended up leaving the workplace, as the only female cnc laser machine operator because of that!

Motheroffive's picture

Motheroffive

image

Agnieszka wrote: Thinking

Agnieszka wrote:

Thinking about some of these things just makes me mad as hell.  
 

 

Me, too, Nishy. I can tell you how it's taken me nearly a decade to recover financially from my separation and divorce from my first husband. I have provided ALL of the care of our children while he went off to make great coin in his career (which I helped him establish). And he is out of compliance with a negotiated judge's order which I will have to pursue in court. Fortunately, I have the ability to pursue this without hiring a lawyer but good god, it's brutal.

 

And no doubt he is whining about how family court favours women...wah, wah, wah..

musicsooths's picture

musicsooths

image

When it comes to financial

When it comes to financial compensation in the United Church it doesn't matter if you are male of female the basic grid is the same it depends on the type of ministry ie ordained or student etc then it depends on years of service. Seems pretty fair to me.

crazyheart's picture

crazyheart

image

musicsooths, I agree and was

musicsooths, I agree and was trying to figure why it is said women make less. I think it is the over and above the pastoral charge pays. Male  would get more than female. Although if they are in team they should be both compensated the same according to their category. I don't think that happens.

I know a church where the congregation always gave the ordained an increase above minimum and the Staff Ass  got nothing.

musicsooths's picture

musicsooths

image

Every staff member at the

Every staff member at the church I work for got the same percentage raise it has always been that way.There are 2 females and one male.

seeler's picture

seeler

image

crazyheart - the church I was

crazyheart - the church I was in before paid the minimum - male or female got the minimum for that category.  The church I am in now uses team ministry in the true sense of the word.  The two individuals are considered a team - they work out their responsibilities (One does visitation this month / the other the next;  one serves on one committee for a term, the other the next; one is really interested in adult education, the other in youth; both preach {and it isn't advertized in advance who will be in the pulpit}.  If the other is in church (s)he takes part in the prayers, etc.)  They get paid a percentage above their minimum - ie  if one is category C she gets a certain percentage of that salary; if the other is category B he gets the same percentage of that salary.   Usually we try for male / female balance - but sometimes may have two male.  I don't remember having two female.  But if the next minister is female, and the longer term male retires in a few years, then it is possible that we might have two female.

 

However, I think this arrangement is unusual in the Maritimes.   Most churches that I am aware of that are large enough and afluent enough to have two ordained ministers have a senior and a junior position - with the senior commanding the bigger salary and having the higher profile in churh affairs.  Usually, but not always, the senior would be more experienced and in a higher category.  If not - say if the church hires an older person as the second minister as assistant - the church would top up the 'senior' minister to match or exceed the second minister's salary and maintain the hierarchy.

 

WaterBuoy's picture

WaterBuoy

image

Are there unique m'n in all

Are there unique m'n in all that chit?

 

Perhaps you'd like to sink the vessel with all aboard ... book of Kells ... flat out answers with out bowing the pages to see all creation's gifts. It is the aspect that counts in the beginning when we are too green to look between the leaves for the light hand and h'art. The Hero is the strong sort ... it's tradition until some body breaks IT ... the way it is transcended to the child within ...

 

Is inital passion all that counts in the larger game, or is there need for some clear intelligence? Consider this in the teaching of institutions of old thought! Is a thinking devil revered? What did they do with Christ ... ain't that Light thinking? Iluminations ... d'Luci fearing devil! It assists along a dark wah ... yah wah in the big inning of the game; who wins?

Back to Religion and Faith topics