And so the debate rages on. This year Wiarton Willie has predicted an early spring. However, Punxatawny Phil is calling for six more weeks of winter. Quite the argument.
Any thoughts?
© WonderCafe. All Rights Reserved
Brought to you by the people of The United Church of Canada
Opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of WonderCafe or The United Church of Canada
Comments
MistsOfSpring
Well, aside from the fact
Posted on: 02/02/2012 13:31
Well, aside from the fact that it's mostly superstition, the fact that they are in different geographic areas probably has something to do with it! There might very well be something behind the shadow idea meteorologically. In the winter, the brightest days tend to be the coldest, and the really overcast days tend to be warmer with more precipitation. Perhaps someone noticed a long, long time ago that when February started with bright, freezing days the winter tended to go on longer, thus the "sees his shadow and hides" story was born. Growing up in North Bay, I never did understand the "six more weeks of winter" vs. "early spring" though. Up there, six more weeks of winter would BE an early spring!
MistsOfSpring
Here's an article I just
Posted on: 02/02/2012 13:34
Here's an article I just found about it:
The science of...Groundhog Day?
Groundhog: a groundhog coming out of it's burrow
A furry little rodent crawls out of its den, is scared by its own shadow, and that means we'll have six more weeks of winter? Sounds like silly superstition, doesn't it? But several parts of the Groundhog Day legend do in fact have a basis in science and careful observation of nature:
Astronomy: Before calendars came into widespread use, Europeans divided the year into four parts, using the Winter Solstice (the shortest day of the year, around December 21), the Summer Solstice (the longest day, roughly June 21), and the Spring and Fall Equinoxes (days when night and day are exactly equal, March 21 and September 21) as signposts. The days halfway in-between these four milestones are called cross-quarter days.
February 2 lies midway between the Winter Solstice and the Spring Equinox. Some ancient Europeans considered it the first day of spring (a bit early, if you ask me!) Romans held a purification festival called Februus at this time, to prepare their fields for planting. (The festival's torchlight parade later evolved into the Christian feast of Candlemas.) The Celts of Ireland celebrated Imbolc on this day, a fertility ritual associated with ewes preparing to give birth.
Animal behavior: Ancient peoples observed animal behavior for clues to changes in the weather. The reappearance of hibernating or inactive animals like badgers, hedgehogs and even bears was a sign of winter's end. When German settlers came to Pennsylvania in the 1700s, they chose the groundhog as the local harbinger of spring.
Even today, we watch for animals to indicate the change of seasons. Geese flying south is a sure sign of fall. In the Midwest and Northeast, we wait for the first robin of spring. Californians wait for the swallows to return to Capistrano. And Ohio residents know it's spring when the buzzards come back to Hinkley.
Meteorology: Ever notice how bright, clear winter days are often very cold? That's because they are caused by high pressure systems. Areas of high pressure pull cold air down from the north. They also sweep away any clouds that might have provided insulation.
Farmers in ancient Europe noticed this relationship, and developed various legends and practices around it. Some of the most noteworthy involved February 2, the old cross-quarter day. An old Scottish poem says:
Other cultures have similar sayings. Of course, the weather on one particular day won't determine the weather for the next six weeks. But, in general, if winter has had a lot of cold, sunny days, one can expect the pattern—and the chilly weather—to continue.
So, Groundhog Day merges three elements of pre-scientific knowledge. It takes a sign of spring — animals emerging from hibernation — and a sign of winter — clear, cold days — and combines them with a date that has astronomical significance.
Unfortunately, each of these elements works better as a general rule of thumb than as a concrete prediction. Put them together in a specific way, and you end up with a superstition: there's no evidence of winters being any harsher or milder after the groundhog sees his shadow. However, each of these elements individually is a testament to ancient people's ability to carefully observe their environment and recognize patterns — which is pretty much what science is all about.
GordW
WHat about Shubecnadie (sp?)
Posted on: 02/02/2012 13:43
WHat about Shubecnadie (sp?) Sam and Balzac Billy? What are their thoughts ont he matter?
Mendalla
Nice article, Mists. Does put
Posted on: 02/02/2012 13:48
Nice article, Mists. Does put the whole thing in a slightly different light, doesn't it?
As for Wiarton Willie, here in Southern Ontario we've been alternating between winter and spring weather all winter so who knows where it's going? We shovelled on the weekend and now we're bare again. Six more weeks of winter like this is effectively an early spring
.
Happy Groundhog Day!
Mendalla
Mendalla
GordW wrote: WHat about
Posted on: 02/02/2012 13:49
WHat about Shubecnadie (sp?) Sam and Balzac Billy? What are their thoughts ont he matter?
Sam voted with Willie. Not sure about Billy.
Mendalla
trishcuit
Damn rodents. Aren't they
Posted on: 02/02/2012 14:51
Damn rodents. Aren't they senile and too old for this now?
gecko46
These was last years
Posted on: 02/02/2012 14:52
These was last years predictions....interesting to compare to 2012.
Mendalla
trishcuit wrote: Damn
Posted on: 02/02/2012 15:45
Damn rodents. Aren't they senile and too old for this now?
Actually, I think the current Willie is third generation or something like that.
Mendalla
Tabitha
I vote for a Penticton Pete
Posted on: 02/02/2012 21:45
I vote for a Penticton Pete or Pentction Pat-that's a gender neutral name!